Navigating Auto Enrolment: A Comprehensive Guide for Employers

Introduction

On the 5th of April 2024, Minister Heather Humphries announced the publication of the Auto Enrolment Retirement Savings System Bill 2024. This significant legislation paves the way for the introduction of a National Automatic Enrolment Savings Authority, tasked with overseeing the implementation of Auto Enrolment (AE) from the 1st of January 2025. This new system is a long-awaited development in Ireland, addressing the country’s lag in pension coverage compared to other OECD countries. For employers, however, this new requirement introduces a range of considerations, particularly in relation to existing pension schemes and the adequacy of the AE scheme itself.

The Framework of Auto Enrolment

The AE system is designed to include all employees between the ages of 23 and 60 who earn €20,000 or more annually. Employees outside this age range may opt-in voluntarily. Key features of the scheme include:

  • Contribution Rates: Both employees and employers will contribute to the scheme, with contributions escalating every three years. The government will also provide a top-up of one-third of the employee’s contribution. By the tenth year of the scheme, total contributions will reach 14% of an employee’s earnings.
  • Opt-Out Provisions: Employees can opt out after six months of participation and during specific periods following each contribution rate increase. Additionally, they can pause or suspend contributions at any time after the initial six-month period, with automatic re-enrolment after two years.
  • Investment Options: Four investment managers will oversee the AE funds, offering low, medium, and high-risk options. Employees will be able to choose their risk preference or default to a standard investment option.
Challenges for Employers

While the AE system aims to broaden pension coverage, it introduces complexities, particularly for employers who already operate pension schemes. These include:

  1. Coordinating Existing Schemes: Employers with existing pension schemes may face administrative challenges in aligning these with the AE scheme. For instance, if some employees are not currently covered under an employer’s pension scheme, they will need to be included in the AE scheme, potentially resulting in the need to manage dual pension systems.
  2. Contribution Levels and Tax Relief: The government’s top-up under AE translates to a tax relief of 25%, which is less beneficial compared to the 40% relief available under many employer-sponsored schemes. This discrepancy could make AE less attractive to employees, particularly those in higher tax brackets.
  3. Scheme Flexibility: AE’s rigid rules around retirement age and lack of options for additional voluntary contributions (AVCs) could be limiting. Employers might prefer to establish their own schemes, allowing greater flexibility in terms of early retirement options and higher contribution levels.
Strategic Considerations for Employers

Given the impending introduction of AE, employers should engage in strategic planning to assess the best course of action. This includes:

  • Reviewing Existing Pension Schemes: Employers should evaluate whether their current pension schemes meet AE requirements and consider adjustments, such as lowering the entry age or making scheme membership compulsory.
  • Considering a Separate Scheme: Establishing a separate employer-sponsored pension scheme could offer more control and benefits, including more attractive tax relief and the ability to tailor contributions and retirement options to better suit employees’ needs.
  • Seeking Professional Advice: Engaging with a Financial Broker is crucial. Brokers can provide insights into the implications of AE for individual employers and help design pension schemes that optimise both employer and employee benefits.

For further details on how to prepare for Auto Enrolment, employers are encouraged to consult with a Financial Broker who can tailor advice to their specific circumstances. As the 2025 deadline approaches, early preparation will be essential in ensuring a smooth transition to this new pension landscape.

Return to site